|
|
|
市場調査レポート
遺伝子検査の直販:米国におけるビジネス展望
Direct-To-Consumer Genetic Testing: Business Prospects in the United States
|
Abstract
The current marketplace for direct-to-consumer (DTC) genetic testing is very
dynamic and fluid. At least 42 DTC genetic testing companies have been
identified to date, and additional market entrants are likely. Firms marketing
and selling genetic tests DTC have numerous factors to consider. This report
focuses on health-related decision-making applications of DTC genetic tests
and examines various components of this emerging business environment:
- The rapidly evolving science and technology
- The complex framework of regulatory oversight
- Social and ethical issues, including genetic privacy
- Consumers' attitudes toward genetic testing
- Activities of companies shaping this sector
- Views of industry leaders through exclusive interviews
Genetic testing has come a long way since development of the first genetic
test in 1963. According to the National Institutes of Health, almost 1,500
genetic tests are now in use. Under the traditional business model, tests are
performed with a physician' s involvement, from ordering the test to
communication of its results. But with the confluence of the Internet and
completion of the Human Genome Project, the procurement of genetic tests is
migrating from health professional-controlled domains to cyberspace, where
these tests are available to anyone. Marketing and selling genetic tests
directly to consumers not only adds a new business model that can exclude the
consumer' s physician but raises scientific, regulatory, and even ethical
issues.
Direct-To-Consumer Genetic Testing: Business Prospects in the United
States aims to sort out these complex issues surrounding the consumer
business of scanning or sequencing genomes for health-related genetic
information. The Washington-level federal dialog has started over the medical
legitimacy of the genetic tests offered to consumers, how the information is
being used, and the appropriate way to make sure that good scientific,
medical, and ethical standards are set and not compromised. We provide a
detailed look at the current US regulatory framework and how the
“patchwork quilt” of today' s regulations is ripe for reform.
The latest market entrants offering genomic scans or gene sequencing for
disease markers or other personal traits currently have similar business
models but appeal to very different consumer segments. We compare and contrast
the approaches, offerings, and messaging of various DTC genetic testing firms
operating today. We delineate aspects of this emerging business environment
that current or prospective participants may need to consider, given its short
history and its uncertain outlook as the technology evolves, the regulatory
dialog continues, and the voices of many groups - including consumers,
physicians, scientists, entrepreneurs, and public interest groups - are heard.
Importantly, the voice of the consumer cannot be understated.
Direct-To-Consumer Genetic Testing: Business Prospects in the United
States presents a sample of the more recent and relevant research that has
been conducted on consumers' attitudes toward genetic testing, exploring such
issues as their willingness and motivation to have a genetic test, how much
they would pay for it, who they would share the results with, privacy
concerns, and how important they believe physician involvement is. This
information is complemented by in-depth interviews with the industry' s thought
leaders and pioneers, who share their views on current business dynamics and
directions in which the field may go.
Table of Contents
Chapter 1
- GENETIC TESTING: YESTERDAY AND TODAY
- 1.1. PKU: The First Genetic Test
- Phenylketonuria
- Success with PKU Testing Initiates Screening of Newborns for Other
Inherited Diseases
- Newborn Screening Is the Largest Segment of Testing for Gene-Based
Disorders Today
- 1.2. Societal Issues Emerge as Testing for Genetic Diseases Evolves
- Sickle Cell Trait and Tay-Sachs Disease
- Tay-Sachs Disease: Incidence, Etiology, and Pathogenesis
- Genetic Testing of Asymptomatic Gene Carriers Influences Family
Reproductive Decisions
- The Next Wave of Carrier Screening: Neural Tube Defects, Cystic Fibrosis,
and Huntington' s Disease
- 1.3. NIH Helps Redefine Genetic Testing for a New Age
- Adoption of DNA “Fingerprinting” Is Embraced
- 1.4. BRCA1 and BRCA2: A New Breed of Genetic Testing for Hereditary
Breast and Ovarian Cancer (HBOC
- Background on Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer
- Myriad Genetics Commercializes HBOC Genetic Testing
- DTC Genetic Testing Rapidly Expands Following Myriad' s DTC Marketing
Success
- 1.5. Genetic Testing in Medicine Today
Chapter 2
- TODAY' S REGULATION OF GENETIC TESTING
- 2.1. The Emerging Business Environment
- An Evolving Supply Chain Embracing New Technologies Drives a Growing Need
for Regulatory Reform
- 2.2. Regulatory Oversight
- Several Agencies Have Oversight of Clinical Laboratory Tests and Devices,
but Regulatory Gaps Exist
- An Overview of How Genetic Testing Is Currently Regulated in the United
States
- FDA' s Role Covers Equipment, Reagents, and Laboratory Tests
- Medical Devices and In Vitro Diagnostics (IVDs)
- Analyte Specific Reagents (ASRs)
- Laboratory Developed Tests (LDTs)
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Regulates Laboratories, Their Testing Services, and Their Reimbursement
- The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Oversees All Print, Media, and Internet Advertising
- The CDC' s Role Is Primarily One of Scientific Advisor
- DHHS Addresses Issues Associated with Genetic Testing under the Secretary' s Advisory Committee on Genetics,Health, and Society (SACGHS)
- 2.3. Business Implications
- The US Federal Regulatory Environment Favors Entrepreneurial Genetic
Testing Companies
- .....But Each of the 50 States Has Its Own Suite of Regulations, Creating
Confusion for DTC Companies
- Recent Regulatory Initiatives: States Step In When Federal Regulators
Appear Slow to Act
- New York State Quietly Begins the Challenges
- California' s Recent Citations to DTC Companies Were Accompanied by Print Media and Online Fanfare, Especially in the Gene-Blogosphere Community
- What Was At Stake for Personal Genomics Companies in the California Order?
- How Did Companies Respond to Regulatory Challenges?
- The Outcome and Remaining Issues
- Implications of the California Decision
- What Remaining Issues Could Surface With Other State or Federal Regulators
- Personal Information Services versus Medical Testing Data
- How Are a “Diagnostic” or Clinical Laboratory Test and an “Authorized Provider” Legally Defined?
- Does Telling Someone They Have a Certain Genetic Profile, or Providing Them With a Genetically Based Disease-Risk Assessment, Constitute Relevant Clinical Information?
- California Regulators, As Well As Others in the Medical and Federal Policy Communities, Have Argued That DTC Genetic Testing Companies Pose a Danger to Consumers
- 2.4. The Regulatory Outlook: Federal Regulation Grows More Likely
- Congressional Activities
- What Lies Ahead
- 2.5. Points to Ponder for Personal Genomics Companies
- 2.6. The Genetic Information and Non-Discrimination Act of 2008
(GINA)
- GINA Removes Some, But Not All, Concerns Relating to
- Protection from Genetic Discrimination
Chapter 3
- DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER GENETIC TESTING: THE INDUSTRY TODAY
- 3.1. Will Medical Genetics Evolve To A Consumer Business?
- The “Distribution Revolution”
- 3.2. Direct-To-Consumer Genetic Testing Companies
- Industry Segmentation Today
- Law Enforcement/Forensics
- “Recreational Genomics/Genetics
- Ancestry/Genealogy Testing
- Personal Traits
- Nutritional Genetics/Genomics
- A Dynamic and Fluid Marketplace
- 3.3. For Personal Genomics, Myriad Genetics Helps Set the Stage
- 3.4. Direct-To-Consumer Genetics and Genomics: Personal Genomics
Companies Launched in November 2007
- New Genome-Scan Entrants Celebrated Their First Birthday in November 2008
- 23andMe
- Navigenics
- deCODEme
- Knome
- 3.5. Other DTC Genetic Testing Companies Debuted a Little Earlier, With
Less Fanfare
- DNA Direct
- Other Genetic Testing Companies Abound
Chapter 4
- UNDERSTANDING CONSUMERS.....THE BIGGEST VARIABLE IN THE PERSONAL
GENOMICS BUSINESS EQUATION
- 4.1. A Survey Sampling: Attitudes about Genetics, Genomics, and Genetic
Testing Among Different Consumer Groups
- Burrill & Company/ChangeWave Research' s Personalized Medicine and Wellness
Survey, May 2008
- Cogent Research' s “Cogent Genomics Attitudes and Trends”
(CGAT) Survey, 2008
- 4.2. Consumer Segmentation: Sorting the US Population by Opinions,
Attitudes, and Values Regarding Use of Genetic Information for Health
Optimization
- 4.3. Physician Market Research: Important, But Still Limited
- 4.4. The Bottom Line Derived From Preliminary Research
Chapter 5
- THE BUSINESS OUTLOOK FOR DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER GENETIC TESTING
- 5.1. Rapid Technology Change
- The Archon X Prize
- The Race to Commoditization.....The $1,000 Genome
- Information Overload: So We Can Sequence an Entire Human Genome.....Now
What?
- 5.2. Likely Regulation
- 5.3. An Uncertain Future with Consumers
- 5.4. Will Consumer Genomics Be a Means to a Different End?
Chapter 6
- EXPERT INTERVIEWS
- 6.1. Linda Avey, Cofounder, 23andMe, Mountain View, CA
- 6.2. Mari Baker, Chief Executive Officer, Navigenics, Redwood Shores, CA
- 6.3. George Church, PhD, Professor of Genetics, Harvard Medical School,
Director, Lipper Center for Computational Genetics, Boston, MA; Founder,
Knome, Cambridge, MA
- 6.4. Fred Ledley, MD, Professor and Chair, Natural Sciences Department,
Bentley University; Founder and Chair of My Genome
- 6.5. Gilbert Leveille, PhD, Executive Director, Wrigley Science Institute,
William Wrigley Jr. Company, Chicago, IL; Scientific Advisory Board Member,
Sciona, Aurora, CO
- 6.6. Ryan Phelan, Chief Executive Officer, DNA Direct, San Francisco, CA
- 6.7. Dietrich Stephan, PhD, Cofounder and Chief Science Officer,
Navigenics, Redwood Shores, CA
- 6.8. Peter Vitulli, Chief Executive Officer, Sciona, Aurora, CO
- 6.9. Christy White, Founder and CEO, Cogent Research, Cambridge, MA
Appendix A
- RECOMMENDED NEWBORN SCREENING TESTS FOR US BIRTHS
Appendix B
- GENERIC COPY OF CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH' S
“CEASE-AND-DESIST” LETTER SENT TO 13 GENETIC TESTING COMPANIES
Appendix C
- SELECTED COMPANY PROFILES
- 23andMe
- Management Summary and Board of Directors
- Company Vision and Mission
- Genetic Testing Services
- BioMarker Pharmaceuticals
- Company Description
- Products and Services
- Dietary Supplement Products
- Management Team
- Board of Directors
- Scientific Advisory Board
- Technology Platforms
- Consumer Genetics
- Company Description and Mission
- Management
- CyGene Direct (CyGene Laboratories)
- Background and Description
- Mission and Vision
- Products and Services Offered (since 2006)
- Management
- Technology Developments
- Alliances
- Scientific Advisory Board
- Financial Summary
- deCODE genetics
- Company Description
- Recent Scientific Developments
- Financial Summary
- DNA Direct
- Company Description
- Mission
- Business Model
- Company Standards and Criteria for Offered Tests
- The Test Purchasing Process
- Privacy and Security
- Investors
- Management
- Services Offered
- Other Company Initiatives
- Board of Directors
- Medical Advisors
- Genelex Corporation
- Company Description
- Company Mission
- Products and Services
- Awards and Recognition
- Company Licenses
- Management
- Other Products Offered
- Knome
- Company Description
- Partnerships
- Management and Advisors
- Technology
- Products and Services
- LabCorp
- Company Description
- Management Team
- Board of Directors
- Genetic Testing Capabilities
- LifeCode
- Company Description
- Navigenics
- Company Background
- Management
- Mission and Vision
- Genetic Testing Services
- Other Information
- Navigenics' Clinical Advisory Board
- Navigenics' Scientific Advisory Board
- Navigenics' Genetics Counseling Task Force
- Navigenics' Policy and Ethics Task Force
- Sciona
- Company Description
- Investors
- Products and Services
- Management
- Technology
- Board of Directors
- Scientific and Business Advisory Board
- Current Research Collaborations
- SeqWright
- Company Description
- Mission
- Products and Services
- Overview of Genomic Profiling Service
- Professional Staff
- Scientific Advisory Board
- Regulatory Compliance
- Smart Genetics
- Company Description
- Mission
- Management Team
- Board of Trustees
- Expert Advisors
- Product Offerings
- Suracell
- Company Description
- Management and Advisory Team
- Product Lines
- Partnerships
- Financial Summary
- References
- Company Index with Web Addresses
|

|